What To Do When the Other Driver Is Lying
Posted On: March 24, 2025This content has been reviewed by Brian P. Hodgkiss
Car accidents are already difficult to deal with, but when the other driver twists the truth, the situation becomes even more stressful. They might deflect the blame, exaggerate details, or flat-out lie to avoid responsibility, which can complicate your claim and put your compensation at risk.
Fortunately, you can protect yourself and secure a fair settlement. Learn what to do when the other driver lies and how qualified Appleton car accident lawyers can assist with your claim.
How False Claims Can Impact Your Case
When the other driver is dishonest about an accident, it can have serious consequences for your car accident case. Insurance companies rely on statements from both parties, police reports, and physical evidence to determine liability, and any inconsistencies can work against you. Here’s how dishonesty can affect the claim:
- False statements might shift the blame, making you appear at fault.
- The insurer may deny your claim based on conflicting reports.
- Disputed liability could reduce your settlement.
- Disputes can drag out the claims process, delaying compensation.
- Without solid proof of the truth, recovering damages may become more difficult.
That’s why gathering strong evidence and seeking legal help from an experienced car accident lawyer as soon as possible is crucial. A skilled attorney can help you counter false claims and present the facts clearly.
Why Legal Representation Matters Early On
Because insurance companies often side with the most convincing version of events, working with a skilled lawyer early can make a huge difference to the outcome of your claim. An experienced attorney can:
- Preserve Critical Evidence: Your lawyer will help collect police reports, surveillance footage, and witness statements before they disappear.
- Prevent You From Being Manipulated: Insurance adjusters may try to get you to admit fault or contradict yourself. An attorney can communicate on your behalf to protect your case.
- Challenge the Other Driver’s Lies: Your legal team can subpoena phone records and dashcam footage or hire accident reconstruction experts to refute false claims.
If you suspect the other driver is lying, contact Brian Hodgkiss Injury Lawyers immediately. The sooner your attorney starts building your case, the stronger your claim will be.
While an attorney can help guide your claim, collecting strong evidence at the scene is the first step in protecting yourself.
How To Gather Evidence at the Accident Scene
If you suspect the other driver is lying or might misrepresent the facts later, collecting evidence immediately after the crash protects your rights.
- Take Photos and Videos: Capture images of vehicle damage, skid marks, traffic signals, road conditions, and visible injuries. Videos can also help document the aftermath.
- Obtain Witness Statements: If bystanders saw the accident, ask for their contact information and request a brief statement.
- Call the Police: Request a police report to document an official account of the crash. Provide a clear and accurate statement of your version of events.
- Look for Available Video Footage: Look for traffic cameras, surveillance footage, or dashcam recordings that may have captured the accident from multiple angles, offering unbiased evidence of what happened.
- Document Everything: Write down details like the time, location, weather conditions, and conversations you had with the other driver while they are fresh in your mind. A written record could help challenge false claims in the future.
Steps To Take if the Other Driver Is Lying
If you realize that the other driver is making false claims, take the following steps to protect your case:
| Step | What To Do | Why It Helps Your Claim |
| Correct the Police Report | Contact law enforcement promptly about any discrepancies in the report and provide supporting evidence. Request a correction or an addendum with additional details. | Prevents inaccuracies from harming your caseAdds an official record of the truth |
| Consult With Witnesses | Reach out to witnesses to clarify details or gather new information. Contact anyone who didn’t give a statement at the scene. | Includes witness statements to challenge false claimsSupports your account with outside perspectives |
| Preserve Physical Evidence | Keep damaged property, such as broken vehicle parts or torn clothing, as proof of impact severity. | Refutes claims of a minor crashShows the crash’s impact with physical proof |
| Maintain Medical Records | Save all medical records, treatment plans, and expense receipts to document the full extent of injuries. | Confirms injury severity if fault is disputedConnects medical costs to the accident |
| Work With an Accident Reconstruction Expert | Hire an expert to analyze crash evidence and reconstruct the accident based on physical proof. | Offers expert analysis to counter false claimsUses evidence to reconstruct the crash accurately |
Let Brian Hodgkiss Injury Lawyers Fight for You
If the other driver is being dishonest, proving your case can be challenging. At Brian Hodgkiss Injury Lawyers, we handle the burden of proving what happened, allowing you to focus on your recovery while we gather the evidence to challenge false claims.
With millions recovered for clients, our team knows how to expose inaccuracies and hold insurers accountable. Contact us today for a free consultation to protect your claim and secure the compensation you’re owed.
Contact Us for a Free Case Evaluation
"*" indicates required fields
